-
要求中国核裁军荒谬至极
最后更新: 2019-10-17 10:21:18Zhoubo:It’s Absurd To Ask China To Disarm
The Chinese government sent Vice Premier Liu He to the U.S. in April with a brief to settle the tariff war between Beijing and Washington. But during an Oval Office news conference to address the progress of trade negotiations, President Trump abruptly changed the subject: “Between Russia and China and us, we’re all making hundreds of billions of dollars’ worth of weapons, including nuclear, which is ridiculous.” Mr. Trump has since ordered his administration to prepare a push for new arms-control agreements with Russia and China.
If Mr. Liu was surprised by the pivot from trade to arms control, he wasn’t alone. To Chinese ears, Mr. Trump’s claims make no sense. Between them, the U.S. and Russia possess 90% of the world’s nuclear weapons. China has fewer nuclear warheads (290) than France (300), according to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute.
No wonder China’s Ministry of National Defense essentially laughed at the idea of a three-way deal on arms control involving the U.S. and Russia. For such an agreement to work, either the U.S. and Russia would need to bring their nuclear arsenals down to China’s level, or China would need to increase the size of its arsenal drastically. Neither scenario is realistic.
At the moment, the Trump administration is building up U.S. nuclear capability, developing low-yield warheads for submarine-launched ballistic missiles and tactical nukes for use in battlefield situations. Russian President Vladimir Putin announced in March 2018 that Moscow is developing a nuclear-powered cruise missile with “unlimited range and unlimited ability to maneuver.”
Since China has pledged no first use of nuclear weapons and only seeks a small and effective deterrent force, it has to keep a larger arsenal of ground-based intermediate-range missiles for strategic equilibrium with other nuclear powers. In other words, if China reduces the number of its ground-based intermediate-range missiles, most of which are subject to the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty, it has to increase its nuclear-strike capabilities massively. Which is the “lesser evil” for the West?
China is no stranger to nuclear disarmament. In 1994 China presented a draft of a no-first-use policy to France, Russia, the U.S. and the U.K.—the four other countries in the nuclear club at the time. After India and Pakistan conducted nuclear tests in 1998, China and the U.S. agreed to point their nuclear missiles away from one another. Other nuclear powers followed suit in 2000.
Do we really need another ineffective nuclear-disarmament treaty, as Mr. Trump suggested? The Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons only recognizes the nuclear powers that conducted tests before January 1967. It hasn’t prevented India, Israel and Pakistan—not to mention North Korea—from becoming de facto nuclear states. The 2017 Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons understandably reflects frustration over “the slow pace of nuclear disarmament,” but it probably won’t come into effect. So far only 23 nations have ratified the treaty, which requires 50 to go into force. Ironically, Japan refuses to join. The only country to have suffered a nuclear attack claims to see no use in the treaty.
Washington and Moscow need to take the lead on this issue and reduce the size of their nuclear arsenals if they want to live in a world with fewer weapons. The prospect of this happening appears remote. The U.S. is set to withdraw from the INF treaty on Aug. 2. North Korea refuses to make even superficial concessions without the promise of an economic payoff, and if Iran decides to go for a bomb, Saudi Arabia will follow. Dominoes in Egypt and Turkey would likely fall after that.
The number of nuclear warheads in the world has fallen from about 65,000 at the peak of the Cold War in the mid-1960s to 13,865 at the start of 2019. That’s progress but it didn’t happen by accident. It required brave leaders to make smart decisions.
本文系观察者网独家稿件,未经授权,不得转载。
-
本文仅代表作者个人观点。
- 责任编辑: 李泠 
-
狙击手14年趴1万多小时:我趴着,是为了让更多人站着
2019-10-17 10:10 暖心闻 -
东北大娘硬核马拉松应援:兜风呢?那破玩意儿带它干啥?
2019-10-17 09:44 -
南开100岁生日,教学楼“动”了!
2019-10-17 09:42 中西教育 -
1.5米大蛇一口咬住消防员,牙掉了…
2019-10-17 09:37 -
指挥官下令:只能抢自己的新娘,速度一定要快!
2019-10-17 08:50 习主席带领我们强军 -
习近平亲切会见国庆70周年庆祝活动筹办工作有关方面代表
2019-10-17 08:44 国庆70周年 -
强军健体铸和平:新中国军事体育事业发展纪实
2019-10-17 08:42 第七届世界军人运动会 -
《陈情令》演唱会票价炒到15万?主办方否认官方倒票
2019-10-17 08:25 中国电影 -
“民阵”召集人岑子杰旺角遇袭倒地
2019-10-17 08:20 香港 -
兵马俑里要建酒店?当地官方回应
2019-10-17 08:04 -
他要求叶璇道歉:她针对我,让我儿女丢脸
2019-10-17 07:40 中国雷人秀 -
这10位文艺大咖获评上海文学艺术奖“终身成就奖”“杰出贡献奖”!李强应勇今晚为他们颁奖
2019-10-16 23:12 上海观察 -
重庆文物局:重庆大学博物馆及其所办展览均未备案
2019-10-16 22:33 -
共同打赢打好脱贫攻坚战!李强应勇今天与云南省党政代表团一行共商沪滇扶贫协作
2019-10-16 21:58 上海观察 -
军运会:八一女排3-0完胜美国队 取得开门红!
2019-10-16 21:01 第七届世界军人运动会 -
汽油弹、无人机、引爆装置…港警查获大量证物
2019-10-16 21:01 香港 -
习近平就中蒙建交70周年同蒙古国总统巴特图勒嘎互致贺电
2019-10-16 19:30 中国外交 -
习近平会见新西兰前总理约翰·基
2019-10-16 19:27 中国外交 -
军运会代表团陆续入境,朝鲜唯一全团着军装
2019-10-16 19:13 第七届世界军人运动会 -
第八批全国重点文保单位公布,共762处(名单)
2019-10-16 18:56
相关推荐 -
国防部表态:中方不会在南海问题上任菲胡来 评论 74关于ASML出口管制,荷兰首相在华表态 评论 446警惕!“隐秘”的调查暗藏国家安全风险 评论 121巴总理召开紧急会议,“事关在巴中国公民” 评论 80习近平会见美国工商界和战略学术界代表 评论 27最新闻 Hot
-
银河系中心超大质量黑洞,又一张偏振图像来了
-
竟还有这样给他们洗白的:“善良有爱心”、“胆小不敢杀鸡”…
-
“港独分子”作证:他勾结外国反华政客!
-
这个数据,孟买首次超越北京
-
浙大社会学系第3次更新:赵鼎新再度“荣休”
-
美国务院一官员辞职:自焚军人最后的留言让我难以忘怀
-
日本资助的项目被搁置,斯里兰卡:中国承诺帮我们
-
关于ASML出口管制,荷兰首相在华表态
-
耶伦:我要当面“警告”中国,你们东西太便宜,搞得美国企业破产
-
警惕!“隐秘”的调查暗藏国家安全风险
-
普京反问:我们跨越大洋跑到美国边境了吗?
-
“美国暴露了”
-
“为何总觉得你们的生活方式比我们好?甚至连提问方式都…”
-
中企被迫退出竞标,“欧盟借这招威慑外企”
-
他威胁“不停火就断交”,以色列怒了
-
美媒“拆台”:哪有火车?你咋坐的?
-